New Orleans Business News
The MBS Companies, founded by Michael B. Smuck of Metairie, did not follow through on its plan to purchase this Houston-area apartment complex, which it planned to rename Yellowstone Ranch. The investors' money was used for other purposes
Kenner residents John and Sharon Kochera had been successfully investing for years in Texas apartment complexes managed by the Metairie-based MBS Companies when one day in August 2007, the quarterly distributions stopped.
They soon learned that MBS had not followed through on its plan to purchase a Houston-area apartment complex to be renamed Yellowstone Ranch -- and had used their money for other purposes.
Two-and-a-half years later, most of the hundreds of thousands of dollars they had invested in Yellowstone and other apartment complexes is gone. The Kocheras are losing faith about how much of their retirement money they'll ever see again.
"It's an absolute sheer theft," said John Kochera, who, like his wife, is a Realtor nearing retirement age. "We've seen one person after another who have been involved in creating Ponzi schemes go to prison, and here it is two-and-a-half years after the fact and nothing's happened."
The Kocheras are among the hundreds of local professionals who are out millions of dollars in the MBS carnage. The roster of investors includes a gaggle of doctors from East Jefferson General Hospital, groups of law partners and even an entire golf group.
MBS filed bankruptcy in fall 2007, and most of the company's assets have been seized by banks or liquidated.
Meanwhile, scores of investors have filed suit over their losses, alleging the company misappropriated funds, neglected its deteriorating apartment complexes and kept multiple sets of books to cheat investors. More than a dozen jilted investors were interviewed for this story, and several also have told their tales to federal authorities.
Many hold out hope that fraud charges against MBS principals -- and possibly other people or institutions that played key roles in the apartment deals -- could bring about restitution.
The U.S. attorney's office in New Orleans and the FBI say they cannot confirm or deny the existence of an investigation. No charges have been filed.
Katrina blamed
At the center of the controversy is Michael B. Smuck, a Metairie man who built an empire of about 20 apartment complexes in Texas and Louisiana in the 1980s. That company, the Equity Group, imploded after the federal Tax Reform Act of 1986.
Undeterred, Smuck founded MBS Realty Investors Ltd. in 1987 and began rebuilding. By the time the privately held firm crashed 20 years later, it had grown into one of the largest landlords in the country, with a $1 billion portfolio of about 60 apartment complexes, mostly in Texas.
Exactly why MBS unraveled is a matter of debate. News reports from that time note that 2007 was the year that FEMA began winding down its Hurricane Katrina rental assistance, and say that Smuck failed to anticipate that the easy rental income at his many Houston-area apartment complexes would dry up, leaving him without tenants and with units in need of repair.
About the same time, complaints to the Texas Apartments Association about collapsed balconies, wet ceilings, no hot water, rats, dead animals and overgrown grass at Smuck properties mounted, according to news reports that have been echoed in lawsuits.
Smuck referred calls to defense attorney Ralph Capitelli, who said Smuck's company got into trouble after Katrina because his insurers failed to pay business-interruption claims.
In a federal lawsuit against Hartford Fire Insurance Co. and other insurers, Smuck claims their failure to pay impeded his ability to acquire new properties, refinance existing properties and collect rents.
Hartford counters that there was "a relatively small amount of wind damage" at Smuck's offices at the Galleria in Metairie.
Many investors question whether storm damage at those offices was just a convenient excuse to explain the lack of business records and why money couldn't be distributed. Bruce Miller, a tax attorney who invested in many of the apartment deals, says the explanation doesn't make sense because rent was being paid at the Texas apartments.
"I started thinking, wait a minute, what's going on here? People are paying rents. Where is the money?" Miller said. "How could Mike say, 'The office was in disarray'?"
Smuck is still working for MBS, where he is advising the bankruptcy trustee about transferring many of the complexes to new management. He still lives in an upscale house on Palm Vista Drive in Metairie.
'Too good to be true'
In 1995, Smuck had partnered with Ed White, a Metairie commercial real estate broker who is active in religious circles and well-known among local business leaders. Until the MBS scandal started eating up his time, White also hosted a local Sunday-night television show called the Freedom Series that delved into issues of faith and free enterprise. White also has a self-published book, Financial Freedom.
Through his firm Ed White & Associates Inc., White began recruiting MBS investors. Many, but not all, of his recruits were wealthy individuals who qualified to be accredited investors as required by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, a designation that is supposed to certify that investors are seasoned enough to participate in high-risk deals and survive financially if they fail.
Investors say most deals had a minimum buy-in of $50,000. They would get handsome quarterly distributions of at least 8 percent and sometimes as high as 15 percent and would cash out when complexes were sold. The investments worked so well that many poured their money back into the next deal and excitedly told friends and family about the opportunity, which often earned them a commission.
Slidell attorney Richard Regan, for example, knew White as a friend and client, and began investing in MBS apartments in the mid-1990s. He reinvested every dime he ever made into the next deal -- so he's now out hundreds of thousands of dollars.
"I know now it was too good to be true. Everything I earned, I put back in and, if I earned more money, I invested that, too," Regan said. "And of course, I got a lot of friends and relatives in it, like a lot of other people. I feel guilty."
Regan reported the scheme to the FBI more than two years ago. Most investors say they didn't know about Smuck's failed venture in the 1980s. But MBS's long successful track record seemed worthy of investment and paid distributions like clockwork. And White's religious convictions, public profile and gregarious nature put people at ease.
One person who did know of Smuck's earlier chapter was Miller. He had a client who got burned with the Equity Group apartments failure back in the 1980s and said the problem wasn't the real estate crash; it was that Smuck moved money from one complex to another to pay debts, when finances should have been kept separate.
Miller said that White knew, too, but White assured him that Smuck had started over and the investments were legitimate. Miller flew see the Houston apartments for himself. The apartments seemed well-managed, the financial statements were good, and White and others putting together the deals were credible.
Miller began investing in the mid-1990s, and he invested and reinvested in 20 apartment deals. He's still waiting for the lion's share of his money. Miller and others question the explanations they've been given and whether the financial statements they saw along the way were real.
White's role
White said he realized all was not well with the apartments when he got a call from an MBS attorney in September 2007 about cash flow problems.
White said he hadn't known anything was wrong with the 28 MBS apartment complexes he was involved with, because when he would visit the properties in Texas, they looked fine from the outside.
White took his concerns to federal law enforcement officials, and because of those inquiries, he said he can't discuss what went wrong with the apartments. "I don't want to do anything to jeopardize the investigation," he said.
White held meetings with investors in fall 2007 to keep them apprised of what he knew, and took actions on their behalf.
Eighteen of the 28 complexes were lost in the bankruptcy, but White was able to save 10.
He sold three apartment complexes to earn money for investors, entered into joint ventures on two others, and pumped his own money into five of them to stave off foreclosure. His company is now managing those properties.
He sued Whitney National Bank on the investors' behalf for allowing Smuck to take the Yellowstone checks and deposit them into another account. The case has been settled.
And while PNC Bank claims in a suit that Smuck improperly transferred to White funds it had a secured interest in, and White improperly transferred them to investors, White has sued PNC Bank. He says he relied on the bank to investigate MBS before making loans, and that the bank didn't do its due diligence.
White has earned a number of grateful fans, who say that he has been their conduit for information and their lifeline in any hope of restitution.
"It was fine for a few years until Smuck ran off with a bunch of money," said New Orleans lawyer Frank Bruno, who had been investing in MBS deals for about eight years before they stopped. "I've got faith in Ed. He's trustworthy."
But others are distrustful that all of their information about the situation has come from White, who was Smuck's partner. They say if White was earning fees and commissions for his work, then he is also liable.
"Personally, I just don't believe that he was on top of his game. I think that things were going so well for so long for these guys, Ed didn't suspect anything was wrong. He didn't visit any of the properties in question to see that they were maintained properly," said Kochera. "I have my doubts."
Anthony Tridico, a physician with several hundred thousand dollars in the MBS apartments, wants answers.
"We all feel betrayed. We're angry. We're bitter. It was a Ponzi-type scheme and, supposedly, he knew nothing about it," Tridico said. "Why has two to three years gone by? This is ridiculous. We've been given a story. The only information it seems we can get is through Ed White, and Ed White was Mr. Smuck's partner."
Similarly, Robert Schimek, an 84-year-old ophthalmologist with about $250,000 in the MBS deals, said the explanations don't add up.
"According to Ed White, Mike Smuck started all this underhanded, fraudulent activity, taking money off the table and into his pocket. He said he was completely unaware of it. If you're a co-general partner, you're responsible," said Schimek. "He was collecting money and asking us to make contributions. We were really counting on him to make sure they were good investments."
White says there's no way he could have known what was going on because, while he saw financial statements on individual apartment complexes, he couldn't see how it all fit together under the MBS umbrella.
Moreover, he was the biggest local investor, so it wouldn't have been in his interest to let things slide. He even invested in the last deal, Yellowstone.
"I lost millions of dollars on this thing. I am not that stupid," White said. "Let me assure you, if I knew what was going on, I wouldn't have invested. It was well-concealed."
White says he has been assisting federal investigators and is not a target of any inquiries. He has hired defense attorney Donald "Chick" Foret, but Foret said that's only because of his familiarity with the federal investigation process.
"He is absolutely not a target. Ed White is a victim along with the other victims," Foret said. "Ed did hire me to help he and other investors because he knows that I'm familiar with the federal system. The purpose is to maximize restitution for all the investors."
In the meantime, for investors like Gary Auer, founder of the Kenner concrete and construction company F&G Services Inc., the consequences are real.
Auer got hit with a double whammy. Not only did he invest $75,000 with MBS in his first real estate deal with Yellowstone, but his wife's son-in-law worked in Antigua for R. Allen Stanford, the Texas financier who has been charged with operating an international Ponzi scheme, so he invested about $500,000 there.
"I'm still working now. I had planned on retiring last January," said Auer, who is trying to look in the bright side. "You've got a tax write-off. It's theft."
They soon learned that MBS had not followed through on its plan to purchase a Houston-area apartment complex to be renamed Yellowstone Ranch -- and had used their money for other purposes.
Two-and-a-half years later, most of the hundreds of thousands of dollars they had invested in Yellowstone and other apartment complexes is gone. The Kocheras are losing faith about how much of their retirement money they'll ever see again.
"It's an absolute sheer theft," said John Kochera, who, like his wife, is a Realtor nearing retirement age. "We've seen one person after another who have been involved in creating Ponzi schemes go to prison, and here it is two-and-a-half years after the fact and nothing's happened."
The Kocheras are among the hundreds of local professionals who are out millions of dollars in the MBS carnage. The roster of investors includes a gaggle of doctors from East Jefferson General Hospital, groups of law partners and even an entire golf group.
MBS filed bankruptcy in fall 2007, and most of the company's assets have been seized by banks or liquidated.
Meanwhile, scores of investors have filed suit over their losses, alleging the company misappropriated funds, neglected its deteriorating apartment complexes and kept multiple sets of books to cheat investors. More than a dozen jilted investors were interviewed for this story, and several also have told their tales to federal authorities.
Many hold out hope that fraud charges against MBS principals -- and possibly other people or institutions that played key roles in the apartment deals -- could bring about restitution.
The U.S. attorney's office in New Orleans and the FBI say they cannot confirm or deny the existence of an investigation. No charges have been filed.
Katrina blamed
At the center of the controversy is Michael B. Smuck, a Metairie man who built an empire of about 20 apartment complexes in Texas and Louisiana in the 1980s. That company, the Equity Group, imploded after the federal Tax Reform Act of 1986.
Undeterred, Smuck founded MBS Realty Investors Ltd. in 1987 and began rebuilding. By the time the privately held firm crashed 20 years later, it had grown into one of the largest landlords in the country, with a $1 billion portfolio of about 60 apartment complexes, mostly in Texas.
Exactly why MBS unraveled is a matter of debate. News reports from that time note that 2007 was the year that FEMA began winding down its Hurricane Katrina rental assistance, and say that Smuck failed to anticipate that the easy rental income at his many Houston-area apartment complexes would dry up, leaving him without tenants and with units in need of repair.
About the same time, complaints to the Texas Apartments Association about collapsed balconies, wet ceilings, no hot water, rats, dead animals and overgrown grass at Smuck properties mounted, according to news reports that have been echoed in lawsuits.
Smuck referred calls to defense attorney Ralph Capitelli, who said Smuck's company got into trouble after Katrina because his insurers failed to pay business-interruption claims.
In a federal lawsuit against Hartford Fire Insurance Co. and other insurers, Smuck claims their failure to pay impeded his ability to acquire new properties, refinance existing properties and collect rents.
Hartford counters that there was "a relatively small amount of wind damage" at Smuck's offices at the Galleria in Metairie.
Many investors question whether storm damage at those offices was just a convenient excuse to explain the lack of business records and why money couldn't be distributed. Bruce Miller, a tax attorney who invested in many of the apartment deals, says the explanation doesn't make sense because rent was being paid at the Texas apartments.
"I started thinking, wait a minute, what's going on here? People are paying rents. Where is the money?" Miller said. "How could Mike say, 'The office was in disarray'?"
Smuck is still working for MBS, where he is advising the bankruptcy trustee about transferring many of the complexes to new management. He still lives in an upscale house on Palm Vista Drive in Metairie.
'Too good to be true'
In 1995, Smuck had partnered with Ed White, a Metairie commercial real estate broker who is active in religious circles and well-known among local business leaders. Until the MBS scandal started eating up his time, White also hosted a local Sunday-night television show called the Freedom Series that delved into issues of faith and free enterprise. White also has a self-published book, Financial Freedom.
Through his firm Ed White & Associates Inc., White began recruiting MBS investors. Many, but not all, of his recruits were wealthy individuals who qualified to be accredited investors as required by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, a designation that is supposed to certify that investors are seasoned enough to participate in high-risk deals and survive financially if they fail.
Investors say most deals had a minimum buy-in of $50,000. They would get handsome quarterly distributions of at least 8 percent and sometimes as high as 15 percent and would cash out when complexes were sold. The investments worked so well that many poured their money back into the next deal and excitedly told friends and family about the opportunity, which often earned them a commission.
Slidell attorney Richard Regan, for example, knew White as a friend and client, and began investing in MBS apartments in the mid-1990s. He reinvested every dime he ever made into the next deal -- so he's now out hundreds of thousands of dollars.
"I know now it was too good to be true. Everything I earned, I put back in and, if I earned more money, I invested that, too," Regan said. "And of course, I got a lot of friends and relatives in it, like a lot of other people. I feel guilty."
Regan reported the scheme to the FBI more than two years ago. Most investors say they didn't know about Smuck's failed venture in the 1980s. But MBS's long successful track record seemed worthy of investment and paid distributions like clockwork. And White's religious convictions, public profile and gregarious nature put people at ease.
One person who did know of Smuck's earlier chapter was Miller. He had a client who got burned with the Equity Group apartments failure back in the 1980s and said the problem wasn't the real estate crash; it was that Smuck moved money from one complex to another to pay debts, when finances should have been kept separate.
Miller said that White knew, too, but White assured him that Smuck had started over and the investments were legitimate. Miller flew see the Houston apartments for himself. The apartments seemed well-managed, the financial statements were good, and White and others putting together the deals were credible.
Miller began investing in the mid-1990s, and he invested and reinvested in 20 apartment deals. He's still waiting for the lion's share of his money. Miller and others question the explanations they've been given and whether the financial statements they saw along the way were real.
White's role
White said he realized all was not well with the apartments when he got a call from an MBS attorney in September 2007 about cash flow problems.
White said he hadn't known anything was wrong with the 28 MBS apartment complexes he was involved with, because when he would visit the properties in Texas, they looked fine from the outside.
White took his concerns to federal law enforcement officials, and because of those inquiries, he said he can't discuss what went wrong with the apartments. "I don't want to do anything to jeopardize the investigation," he said.
White held meetings with investors in fall 2007 to keep them apprised of what he knew, and took actions on their behalf.
Eighteen of the 28 complexes were lost in the bankruptcy, but White was able to save 10.
He sold three apartment complexes to earn money for investors, entered into joint ventures on two others, and pumped his own money into five of them to stave off foreclosure. His company is now managing those properties.
He sued Whitney National Bank on the investors' behalf for allowing Smuck to take the Yellowstone checks and deposit them into another account. The case has been settled.
And while PNC Bank claims in a suit that Smuck improperly transferred to White funds it had a secured interest in, and White improperly transferred them to investors, White has sued PNC Bank. He says he relied on the bank to investigate MBS before making loans, and that the bank didn't do its due diligence.
White has earned a number of grateful fans, who say that he has been their conduit for information and their lifeline in any hope of restitution.
"It was fine for a few years until Smuck ran off with a bunch of money," said New Orleans lawyer Frank Bruno, who had been investing in MBS deals for about eight years before they stopped. "I've got faith in Ed. He's trustworthy."
But others are distrustful that all of their information about the situation has come from White, who was Smuck's partner. They say if White was earning fees and commissions for his work, then he is also liable.
"Personally, I just don't believe that he was on top of his game. I think that things were going so well for so long for these guys, Ed didn't suspect anything was wrong. He didn't visit any of the properties in question to see that they were maintained properly," said Kochera. "I have my doubts."
Anthony Tridico, a physician with several hundred thousand dollars in the MBS apartments, wants answers.
"We all feel betrayed. We're angry. We're bitter. It was a Ponzi-type scheme and, supposedly, he knew nothing about it," Tridico said. "Why has two to three years gone by? This is ridiculous. We've been given a story. The only information it seems we can get is through Ed White, and Ed White was Mr. Smuck's partner."
Similarly, Robert Schimek, an 84-year-old ophthalmologist with about $250,000 in the MBS deals, said the explanations don't add up.
"According to Ed White, Mike Smuck started all this underhanded, fraudulent activity, taking money off the table and into his pocket. He said he was completely unaware of it. If you're a co-general partner, you're responsible," said Schimek. "He was collecting money and asking us to make contributions. We were really counting on him to make sure they were good investments."
White says there's no way he could have known what was going on because, while he saw financial statements on individual apartment complexes, he couldn't see how it all fit together under the MBS umbrella.
Moreover, he was the biggest local investor, so it wouldn't have been in his interest to let things slide. He even invested in the last deal, Yellowstone.
"I lost millions of dollars on this thing. I am not that stupid," White said. "Let me assure you, if I knew what was going on, I wouldn't have invested. It was well-concealed."
White says he has been assisting federal investigators and is not a target of any inquiries. He has hired defense attorney Donald "Chick" Foret, but Foret said that's only because of his familiarity with the federal investigation process.
"He is absolutely not a target. Ed White is a victim along with the other victims," Foret said. "Ed did hire me to help he and other investors because he knows that I'm familiar with the federal system. The purpose is to maximize restitution for all the investors."
In the meantime, for investors like Gary Auer, founder of the Kenner concrete and construction company F&G Services Inc., the consequences are real.
Auer got hit with a double whammy. Not only did he invest $75,000 with MBS in his first real estate deal with Yellowstone, but his wife's son-in-law worked in Antigua for R. Allen Stanford, the Texas financier who has been charged with operating an international Ponzi scheme, so he invested about $500,000 there.
"I'm still working now. I had planned on retiring last January," said Auer, who is trying to look in the bright side. "You've got a tax write-off. It's theft."
No comments:
Post a Comment